What is legalism?
Tuesday, March 3rd, 2009At caregroup last week, we were discussing the ways others have demonstrated Christian love to us and B shared an experience. She was relocating to a new city and some friends of friends were helping her out. They picked her up at the airport, drove her to the grocery store, and dropped her off at her new apartment. Later, they gave her a ride to their church and had her over for dinner. During the dinner conversation, B asked them if they had seen Batman Begins, which was then in theaters, and a conversation about media intake began. The next time she saw them, these loving folks encouraged B to carefully guard her media intake and gave her a book on the subject. B read the book and appreciated the way that these mere acquaintances cared enough for her that they would attempt to help her into greater holiness. She felt loved.
Our caregroup leader questioned how it is possible to distinguish between what these folks did and the dreaded L-word–legalism.
And then it hit me: legalism is often in the eye of the beholder.

In modern Evangelicalism, especially Reformed circles, “legalism” is a term of unrivaled opprobrium. While true legalism deserves such infamy–it is by grace through faith that we are saved and not by the works of the law–we should not slip into a pattern where every time another Christian takes a moral position that we don’t like, we cry, “Legalist!”
Instead, we should define legalism precisely:
Seeking to be–or stay–justified in the sight of God by works of the law.
Under this definition, B’s friends were not being legalistic. They were attempting to walk in a manner worthy of their calling and loved B enough that they wanted her to live that way too. Isn’t this what we want Christian community to look like?


